StatCounter
Tuesday, August 19, 2025
CHINA’S GREAT BALL!
Saturday, August 16, 2025
In the Line of Life and Death
Photos: Author Arup Ratan Basu; the book cover; Indian Air Force Squadron leader Ajay Ahuja
In his book, ‘The Kargil War Surgeon’s Testimony’, Arup Ratan Basu
offers a gripping first-hand account of what it was like to serve on the
frontlines during the Kargil conflict
By Shevlin Sebastian
Arup Ratan Basu was deputed as a general surgeon to the field
hospital in Kargil. To reach Kargil, Arup was flown from Chandigarh to Leh, and
then drove to Kargil on May 19, 1999. The surgeon on duty Major RPS Gambhir was
going on a two-month leave.
One of the first things Arup did when he reached Kargil was
to buy a hardbound notebook at the town bazaar. The aim was to note down his
experiences.
With just a month’s surgical experience, Arup felt
understandably nervous about the assignment. By this time, the skirmish between
the Indian and Pakistan armies had begun in the heights near
Kargil.
On Arup’s first night itself, casualties were brought to the
hospital. At first glance, he realised that they were wounds from bullets or
artillery shell splinters. They hit limbs, necks and shoulders.
Thankfully, Major Gambhir did all the necessary surgical
procedures.
Two days later, Major Ramaprasad told Arup, tongue-in-cheek,
that he had not received a proper reception since he arrived in Kargil. Moments
later, the Pakistani Army responded to that request when there was a booming
noise and the hospital shook.
Arup’s first patient was a 21-year-old sepoy, who had a
splinter on his left armpit. Arup quickly got to work.
Once a sepoy, who was returning to consciousness, as his
anaesthesia wore off, shouted, ‘Of you mother……, just wait till I get you. And
that bi…, who does she think she is. You bloody Benazir, just you wait.’
As Arup wrote, ‘In his reduced mental state, the poor fellow
thought that Benazir Bhutto was still the prime minister of
Pakistan.’
Soon, Arup got settled into the routine of the surgery:
‘scrub, drape, pass the forceps, scissors, suck this area, ligatures, artery
forceps, and hydrogen peroxide, saline and betadine dressing.’
When asked why the casualties were always arriving in the
evenings, a hospital staffer explained that during the day the soldiers were
trying to scale up the peaks to get rid of the Pakistani intruders. So, if they
were shot, they had to lie down till night because the rescuers wanted to avoid
getting shot during the daytime.
As the fighting intensified, one day, Arup received a call
that an officer had been wounded gravely. When he asked the name, he was told
it was Major Vikram Shekhawat of the Jat regiment.
The same seemed familiar. Then he realised that some news
channels had already declared him dead. He bemoaned the inaccuracy of the media
reports.
Arup realised some people had miraculous escapes, to the
detriment of others. Once a lieutenant colonel was travelling in a jeep from
Leh to Kargil. After a while, the colonel took the wheel to give the driver
some rest. As they neared Kargil, an artillery shell exploded and a splinter
pierced the passenger seat and hit the driver.
But when Arup opened up the stomach, he found that the
splinter had missed the spinal cord, the bigger blood vessels of the abdomen
and the right ureter. As Arup wrote, ‘If any of those had been hit, the injury
would have been fatal.’
But not every surgery ended in success.
One day a 22-year-old sepoy was brought in, hit by a
splinter. Despite several hours of surgery, the sepoy died. ‘A healthy and
energetic man was gone forever,’ wrote Arup. ‘Never will I forget the sight of
his pale face and his distended abdomen. He had come to me for help – and what
had I done? I was numb with guilt, shame and disgust.’
During a lull in the fighting, Arup came to know from wounded
soldiers that they lacked proper rations and clothing for the freezing weather.
One captain was suffering from frostbite. He said that he had survived on one
chapati by day and another by night, with occasional dried nuts and sugar
candies. When that ran out, they ate snow and ice to satisfy their hunger
pangs.
‘Of course, we had other things to eat too,’ he said, with a
sardonic smile.
‘Such as?’ Arup asked.
‘We could feast on a steady stream of
bullets.’
Arup was summoned to examine a body in a coffin. This turned
out to be Indian Air Force squadron leader Ajay Ahuja whose MIG 21 was shot
down by a Pakistani heat-seeking missile. When Arup inspected the body he
realised that Ajay had been subjected to torture before being shot.
One day an officer rushed into the mess and begged for water.
When asked why he looked in so much distress, he said that he had seen the
bodies of Captain Saurav Kalia and his team who had been captured by Pakistani
soldiers.
The officer was trembling as he blurted out, ‘I have never
seen such horribly mutilated bodies… their nails had been pulled out, their
earlobes cut away, their eardrums punctured, their eyes gouged out, and their
bones broken. Even their penises were cut off.’
Arup had one thought, ‘Could the Geneva Conventions be simply
ignored like this? Besides, could any human being do such a thing to begin
with?’
There were light moments, too.
On one occasion, the wards lit up with excitement when
Bollywood luminaries, Javed Akhtar, Shabana Azmi, Salman Khan, Javed
Jaffrey, Vinod Khanna, Raveena Tandon and Pooja Batra arrived.
The commanding officer pulled Arup aside, pointed to one of
the patients, and said, ‘Wasn’t that fellow admitted three days ago with
intense back pain and sciatica-like symptoms?’
Arup looked with narrowed eyes and confirmed it.
‘Then how is he jumping from one bed to another trying to get
photographed?’ bellowed the senior officer. ‘Discharge him right
away.’
As India slowly regained control of the peaks, aided by the
firepower of Bofors guns and precision airstrikes, the soldiers began moving up
the peaks. The Pakistani soldiers began to withdraw when their positions became
hopeless. International pressure was also heaped on Pakistan. As a result,
there were fewer casualties for Arup to minister to.
Interestingly, when the Indian soldiers captured bunkers left
by fleeing Pakistanis, they were met with a putrid stench – the bodies of dead
Pakistani soldiers left behind to rot.
Arup’s book offers a raw, eyewitness account of war’s brutal
realities. The sheer waste of human resources, and equipment, the damage to the
environment, the terrible loss of life, and the resulting disruption to normal
life – there is nothing good about war.
Or as Shashi Tharoor wrote, ‘In Basu’s view, it’s not so much
about the futility of war as its untold human cost, which gets muffled beneath
the nationalist pomp and clamour of any war effort – even one like Kargil,
undertaken in self-defence. Yet for the parents who lost their sons, wives,
husbands and children, their fathers, this is the only real consequence of
war.’
Adds Lt General (Retd.) Vinod Bhatia, ‘Basu captures the
human face of the Kargil war. Touching, easy to read, and an interesting
perspective.’
After his short stint of two months, when he did an
astonishing 250 surgeries, as Arup prepared to leave, he fell into a
philosophical mood. ‘The concept of war is based on the idea that others should
be subjugated,’ he wrote. ‘Humans have a desire to dominate others, and control
and possess that which does not belong to them. This insatiable greed has led
to history repeating itself time and time again.’
For his services, Arup received the Yudh Seva Medal.
In 2001, he was deputed to Kabul, following the collapse of
the first Taliban services. He served with distinction for ten months. Later,
he served in various command hospitals of the Army Medical Corps before
retiring to his hometown of Jamshedpur in 2013 where he works as a consulting
gastroenterology surgeon.
Arup has written three books in Bengali. This is his first in
English.
(Published in kitaab.org)
Wednesday, August 13, 2025
The Great Beijing Scribes’ Race
Photo: With Pradeep Paul at the Great Wall of China
COLUMN: TUNNEL OF TIMETuesday, August 05, 2025
Beijing Before the Boom
Pics: Panpan, the mascot for the Beijing 1990 Asian Games, in front of the National Olympic Sports Center in Beijing; the author at the Great Wall of China
By Shevlin Sebastian
Photographs: Nikhil Bhattacharya
It was an incident in a restaurant that really opened one's eyes to the lack of freedom in China.
A Filipino journalist walked in, accompanied by a Chinese girl dressed in a suit.
The restaurant went into a flurry.
A waiter approached her and said in Chinese that she wasn’t allowed inside. The journalist mentioned that she was his guest. The waiter continued to rattle off something in Chinese to the girl. She replied, a defiant look on her face.
The journalist insisted she was with him.
The waiter turned away, but suddenly there was a palpable tension. An elderly head waitress came in, whispered something to the waiter, and withdrew. The girl looked embarrassed now.
But that was not the end of the matter. Within moments, two big, muscular Chinese plainclothesmen with close-cropped hair came in from the kitchen.
They walked past the girl’s table and positioned themselves near the door.
Then a balding head security man, in his mid-60s, joined them. They huddled briefly, then spoke to the waiter. By now, the look of defiance on the girl’s face had turned to fear.
It was a chilling sight: the State asserting its power against the individual.
The individual wilted under the twin forces of fear and helplessness. She ate her meal, but there was no joy in it.
China’s authoritarian control was laid bare in that restaurant in Beijing. Yet, the city had been spruced up for the Asian Games. There were wide avenues, broad sidewalks with flower pots at every corner, flags flying from lamp posts, and, every now and then, someone sweeping the sidewalk with a broom. The roads were wide and smooth, with a separate lane for cycles. It was right-hand drive in China, although most of the cars were of Japanese make.
It would seem a modern city. But what lingered in the air was the unmistakable weight of fear. A glass wall that cuts through daily life.
Crowded, dirty and noisy, the bylanes told a different story. People spat on the streets — an act that would incur fines on the main roads, but was ignored in these alleyways.
The Chinese people, by and large, were wary of foreigners. They had been instructed not to mingle with them. As soon as they saw one, they looked away.
The government added another barrier. Foreigners had to use a separate currency — the Foreign Exchange Certificate (FEC). It differed from the regular Renminbi. Shopping was hard, especially in places not designated for tourists. Some shopkeepers flatly refused to accept the FECs. Even taxi drivers demanded Renminbi.
It was not a free country.
A young Chinese student put it plainly: “China is not a good country to live in. People are scared all the time.”
Cosmetic changes aside, China remained poor. The average monthly income was about 100 yuan (Rs 500). But food was cheap, clothing inexpensive, and rents fixed at just five percent of a person’s salary. Still, mobility was severely restricted.
To travel from one province to another, a special permit was required. Going abroad was nearly impossible.
“How lucky you are,” said a university student wistfully. “We are not allowed to do so.”
The government rarely issued passports. If a businessman wanted to travel abroad, he first had to deposit 10,000 yuan (Rs 50,000) as a guarantee.
And yet, ironically, despite this intense insularity, the Chinese wore unmistakably Western clothes. Men wore shirts and trousers; women wore jeans, skirts, and suits. Only the older generation still clung to traditional attire.
The people in Beijing said that September–October was the best time of the year. The temperature hovered around 20°C, with a beautiful breeze, bright sunlight, and a clear blue sky. There was no need for a pullover and the air was so pure.
Surely Beijing, with its numerous cycles and trolley buses, must be one of the least polluted cities in the world.
But when you went to a restaurant, they muddled your mind.
If you ordered soup with your meals, they would serve it at the end. And if you ordered pudding, they served it at the beginning. And if you asked for a glass of water, they brought boiling water. Amazing!
But they think we want to drink tea all the time, even at 9 p.m.
All this sounds depressing, but there were high points to the trip.
One was the visit to the Great Wall of China. It was 75 km from Beijing. No doubt, it was one of the most incredible sights. A man-made wonder. It was only when one was physically there that one could comprehend its magnificence.
It was a testament to the will and determination of man, to build a wall like this, stretching 6000 km across rugged mountains. It was not a high wall, about 50 ft in height, but very rugged. But the length boggled the mind.
It was built around 700 BC by the Eastern Zhou dynasty to repel invaders. The raw beauty of the place: mountains on all sides, a cool breeze blowing constantly, and the air that came from Siberia. The utter stillness. Just you, the Wall, and the clean air.
What a contrast to Chowringhee in Calcutta at office time.
To walk on the Wall was physically tiring. Up and down it went, and sometimes it was so steep that steps had to be cut into the stone, and handrails inserted, so that we could climb it.
They say that it is the only man-made construction visible from the moon.
The other high point was a 2200-km train journey from Beijing to Canton.
The train was an express and the cost of the hard sleeper ticket was 250 yuan. The railway clerk discouraged this writer from buying a hard sleeper ticket, saying that it was uncomfortable. But it wasn’t. It was equivalent to AC first class in India.
There were three-tier berths filled with upper-class Chinese families. For the average Chinese, 250 yuan meant a fortune. The train was clean and a worker swept the floor every two hours with a wet broom.
Outside, the scenery was exactly as in India: paddy fields, mountains, small huts, towns and trucks on the highway. Although cars seemed non-existent.
And in the midst of it, some drama: a young Bangladeshi had bought a 100 yuan (Rs 500) student’s ticket. At a station, the collector wanted to see his passport to verify whether he was actually a student or not.
In fact, he was a journalist.
By then, a small crowd had collected around him, curious and surprised. But the Bangladeshi was calm in the centre of so much attention. He pretended not to understand, then in sign language said that he was a refugee and brazened his way out. After a while, they left him alone.
Later, he said, with a mocking smile on his face, “Munjia and China have good relations.” (“Munjia,” incidentally, is the Chinese name for Bangladesh.)
When the Bangladeshi was being the centre of attention, one was reminded suddenly of how Ashwini Nachappa became the centre of attention at the Indian Ambassador’s party.
She came in dressed in a black chiffon saree with a halter blouse. She left the Kerala female athletes’ contingent trailing in her wake.
Photographs were snapped of Ashwini, first by photographers, then with photographers, athletes, officials, journalists, and the Indian Ambassador. The poor man’s Flo-Jo had metamorphosed into the Marilyn Monroe of Indian athletics.
The train was one-and-a-half hours late.
We arrived at 9 a.m.
It was with relief that one took another train (and how one bought a ticket in English-ignorant Canton is another story) from Canton and out of China to Hong Kong.
The overwhelming impression is of people stifling under repressive controls, wanting to be free, and yet not confident enough in making that bid for freedom and multiparty democracy. As a student said: “We are waiting for the present leadership to die, before we can hope to make changes.”
Throughout the stay of three weeks, I was so glad to be an Indian. That I could stand at any corner and say anything about Prime Minister V.P. Singh without any fear; that there is a free press at home; that one can travel freely from one part of the country to another without asking permission from anyone, except your wallet.
(Published in The Telegraph Colour Magazine, November 25, 1990)